What the fee table covers and what it leaves out

A marketplace’s fees are well documented. Referral fee, storage and fulfilment costs, a monthly account fee: all of it can be worked out in a spreadsheet beforehand. Done carefully, it tells you fairly precisely what each unit sold costs.

What the table does not show is what a business gives up without ever receiving an invoice for it. Three things belong here: contact with the customer, freedom over pricing and control over how the brand is perceived. None of these items appears in the accounts. All three, however, affect what the brand is worth in three or five years.

That does not make a marketplace the wrong choice. It simply means the calculation is incomplete as long as only fees are compared. The following sections go through the missing items one by one.

Amazon or your own online shop: who owns the customer after the sale

In your own shop, every order creates a customer record. Name, address, email, purchase history and, with consent, permission to send a newsletter. From this you can prompt repeat orders, announce new products and answer questions personally.

On Amazon, that contact essentially stays with the marketplace. Communication runs through an internal messaging system with anonymised addresses. The policies prohibit promotional contact, as well as package inserts pointing to your own shop. The seller sees orders, but builds no relationship.

This is felt most with products people buy again. With skincare, consumables or supplements, a customer’s value lies in the second, third and tenth purchase. On the marketplace, the brand has to win that customer afresh each time. It does so through search, against competing offers and often against paid ads placed right next to its own product.

One testable question helps. How many customers from the last twelve months could you email directly today, with their consent? If the answer is close to zero while revenue grows, it is mainly the marketplace that is growing.

Why the marketplace also shapes the price in your own shop

Many founders assume they can set prices on Amazon and in their own shop independently. Formally, that is true. In practice, one price influences the other.

Amazon compares offers with prices found elsewhere online. If a product is noticeably cheaper outside, the listing can lose visibility. A typical case is that the purchase box stops being shown. This box, known as the Buy Box, is the buy button through which most orders run.

The result is a quiet floor on pricing. Your own shop can hardly be cheaper than the marketplace, even though no referral fee applies there. At the same time, the marketplace price is hard to raise, because competitors are a click away. A loyalty discount in your own shop becomes a trade-off with side effects.

A second problem arises once other sellers offer the same product. Several sellers then share one product page. Whoever sets the lower price stands a good chance of winning the Buy Box, even if they are not the manufacturer. A brand without controlled distribution loses part of its influence over its own retail price.

Who actually speaks for the brand on the product page

On the marketplace, every product page looks much the same. Same typeface, same layout, same placement of price and reviews. For the customer, that is convenient. For a small brand, it means its presence dissolves into the marketplace’s grid.

Brand registration allows enhanced content and a dedicated brand store. That helps, but changes little about the principle. Next to the product sit sponsored ads from competitors, with recommendations for other brands below. The customer compares in seconds, and mainly compares price and star rating.

Customers also tend to credit the purchase to the marketplace rather than the brand. Many remember buying something “on Amazon”, but not from whom. If the parcel arrives late or damaged, the frustration still ends up in the product review. The brand carries the consequences of a process it does not control.

This leads to an insight that runs against intuition. Your own brand work, on social media or in the press, can mostly benefit the marketplace. People who hear about a brand there often search for it straight on Amazon. The advertising budget creates demand, and the marketplace collects the commission and the customer contact.

Amazon or your own online shop: when the answer is both

Despite these items, a marketplace can make sense for small brands. What matters is that each channel has a clearly defined job. The two complement each other when they serve different customers or different moments of purchase.

The marketplace as entry point, the shop as home. Amazon reaches customers who search for a product category and do not yet know the brand. Your own shop is for those who already value it. When this works, some customers find their way to your shop over time, through the brand name and recommendations.

A different range. The marketplace carries a few easily understood core products. Sets, refill sizes, limited editions and subscriptions are only available in your own shop. That way the channels do not compete for the same purchase, and the shop has a reason to be visited.

Added value the marketplace cannot represent. This includes personal advice, guidance on use, a customer account with easy reordering, or personalisation. Your own shop then does not win on price. It wins on something that has no place on a standardised product page.

Clear roles in advertising. Paid campaigns outside the marketplace lead to your own shop, not to the Amazon listing. Advertising on Amazon stays on Amazon. That makes it at least roughly traceable which channel creates which demand.

When a two-channel strategy eats itself

Cannibalisation happens when both channels sell the same product to the same customers at the same price. Revenue then merely shifts, usually towards the marketplace. It is more convenient, delivery is quick, and the customer account already exists.

A typical sequence looks like this: the own shop launches, Amazon follows shortly after. A few months later, marketplace sales grow while the shop stagnates. The team invests less in the shop because it is “not performing”. In fact, the marketplace has taken over customers the shop would have won through its own advertising.

Even a well-planned two-channel strategy has limits. Two channels mean double the upkeep of product data, stock, prices, enquiries and returns. For a team of two or three people, that can cost more than the second channel brings in. In that case it is more honest to choose one channel for now and run it well.

Brands already heavily dependent on the marketplace carry a further risk. An account suspension, a policy change or a competitor with aggressive prices then hits a large share of revenue at once. In that situation, your own shop is less a growth channel than an insurance policy.

How to assess your own starting position

Before a business reorganises its channels, a few sober questions help. None of them requires a tool, only an honest look at your own figures.

Is the product bought again? The higher the share of repeat purchases, the more the missing customer contact on the marketplace weighs.

How interchangeable does the product look on a standard page? Products explained through origin, story or use lose more in the grid than technical standard goods.

Who else sells the product? If resellers list it independently on marketplaces, pricing is already only partly in your hands.

Where does your own advertising lead? If the demand it creates mostly lands on Amazon, the brand is helping to fund the marketplace.

How much revenue would remain without the marketplace? This figure shows how great the dependency is. It also shows whether a sudden loss would be survivable.

The channel decision is not a one-off

Marketplace, own shop or both: the answer shifts with the product range, the brand’s profile and the marketplace’s rules. What was right as an entry point in year one may have become a dependency by year three. It is therefore worth reviewing each channel’s role once a year, using the same questions.

How we plan brand, shop architecture and sales channels together is described under Services.